David Keck’s review page credits Paul Witcover and Realms of Fantasy and links to the former /articles/show/32 address. The surrounding reviews discuss Keck’s fantasy writing, including In the Eye of Heaven and its imagined medieval world.
A collected review page can preserve valuable evidence after a magazine page disappears. It can identify a reviewer and publication, but selections assembled for an author’s website are still excerpts. They should not be expanded into a supposed complete review.
Readers seeking the original assessment can look for the credited excerpts in David Keck’s review collection. Our reading room does not attribute a new review to Witcover or present the old magazine’s critical opinion as its own.